I've naught a clue on this. A title with serious gravitas
at last : >>> [ fortyouncebachelors
Might probably hate it. I'm a 39 oz bachelor myself, or was prenatally, as I recall.
They promise real critiques on rejection. OK.
It's an electronic venue, which means many things. One is, I imagine, that since a website likely has much lower short-term operating expenses than the costs of producing a physically durable paper product, they have the grand opportunity to be less discriminating about whatever they think of as quality. You don't print what you marginally like if the nut is too high, unless there's funny money behind you somewhere.
Of course, what the reader's opinion is of quality and what the editorship might think can differ. That's what makes beauty contests so engaging.