Translation Bakeoff Voting Thread
 

Sincere thanks to Alex Pepple for the invitation to this competition. Quite an honor. I have been astonished by the number of entrants. To all participants and finalists: each of you faced, and now face, a staggering group. Good luck.

Please post your vote in this thread.

I must now - quite literally - see to a corpse; but I will return with mercy and love, to execute judgment.

Yours,
007

1. Bellay
2. Catullus
3. Rilke

1. Bellay
2. Goes
3. Marlowe

1. Rilke
2. Du Bellay
3. Catullus

OO7, you did a fine job. I can't say that I've ever seen better poems to choose from.

1. Catullus (for the wickedness of it)
   
2. Du Bellay (for perfect pitch)
   
3. Scherbakov (for ambition and sentiment)

Yes, kudos to 007. All entrants and contenders salute you!

I have to say I really like the double-blind bake off. You can focus on what is before you without conscious or unconscious consideration of the persons involved.

I. Du Bellay
2. Borges
3. Catullus

I'm not quite ready to vote, but I'd like to extend my thanks to DG007, whose identity I think I can guess from his/her intimate knowledge of Russian and the information tidbit at the top of this thread.

Selecting and commenting for these events is hard work for small reward and serious risk of feeling knocked about by others' comments. Please know that we appreciate what you've done.

Since our DG seems to be under some pressures elsewhere, I hope Alex will let us know how long the polls will be open.

Agreed. I had a strong hunch after the "off the cuff" translation from the Cyrillic earlier this week, then it was confirmed this morning. Regardless, I can't think of any better Distinguished Guest for this bakeoff, and the insights were splendid as always.

Like Mr. Jones, I'm also very fond of the double-blind element of this bakeoff. I think a lot of the traditional bakeoff complaints were forestalled for that very reason.

1. Bellay
2. Desbordes-Valmore
3. Borges

All three of these were ambitious in taking on complex rhymed works and achieving a high degree of success, but I also enjoyed several others, particularly the Marlowe and Goes. Many thanks to the DG and other members for good comments and a high degree of civility in the event overall.

Susan

Catulllus
Bellay