![]() |
Homeschool Tasks
L1: kid -> child L2: big -> wide S2L3: the shades of body fluids -> the hues of fevered skin and bruising S5L2: lineage of -> ancestral; bruised -> scarred S8L1: a darting tsetse fly -> the dogged drone of tsetse fly S8L2: a flock of dropped thoughts -> a scatter of falling thoughts S9L1: straining to reach just one for one message -> fingers grasping at any descending truth concealed S9L2: shape -> shade ------------------------------------------------------ ~~~First revision ~~~
|
I’m still absorbing this, but I think it’s excellent, rich with gorgeously written moments, including the emotionally charged ending. I’m thinking that this is a child observing his surroundings during a time of conflict—perhaps a civil war (?) in an African country. In the end, his father is going off to fight and I envision the child chasing after him behind a tank that is whipping up dust from the road. I thought that the image of the tsetse flies very fitting as they are known for the transmission of diseases. I thought of the passing down of war, the roots of war, from one generation to the next (being infected), especially as the child is depicted as drawing what he observes—how he is impressionable, as children are. Not to mention the cloud of ideas of what to draw swirling around in his head. It’s terrific.
Though God knows I may be wrong about something above, I’m significantly less confident about how I see the coloring book. But what I love about it, intended or not, is that it seems to me that he is drawing over images that are supposed to be colored in. Blurred/changing borders, reality vs the ideal/the neat, etc., all of this comes to mind. Again, I don’t know if this was intended, but boy do I love this idea for this situation. To the point of extreme jealousy, haha. I’m very fond of “big as the mouth of a deflated soccer ball,” “dragging their lineage of shadows,” “pole men” (wow, brutally haunting), “dirt show fomenters,” “heaven hums” and that cloud of tsetse flies, among other moments. It’s probably just me, but I’m a little confused about “snap shut.” And I’m wondering if something like “The crayons he chooses are the shades of body fluids” (or something less rhymey) might make a bit more sense, as certainly not all of the crayons are those colors. Finally, “mechanized” for “mechanical” ?? (Or maybe not…) Beautiful, intricate poem, Alex. |
Hello Alex
Like James I found many enjoyable and intriguing phrases in here. But it was all a bit difficult for me. I kept getting lost in what was happening to whom. But that may be me not trying hard enough. On a pedantic entomological matter, I ‘m pretty sure tsetse flies are mostly solitary. They don’t form clouds or swarms. You might try another species. Joe |
Thank you all for your thoughtful comments on my poem. I appreciate the time you took to engage with it. I’ve now posted a new revision that should make it easier to follow the poem, hopefully!
James, your reading is very close to my intention! You've captured many of the elements I was aiming for - the African setting, a child processing conflict through drawing, and the emotional weight of the ending. The one aspect that might not have come through clearly concerns Papa's situation—rather than going off to fight, he's actually a victim of the "New Order." Hopefully, that’s clearer in the revision! Joe, thank you for your careful reading and for the entomological correction about tsetse flies. You're absolutely right that they don't typically swarm, and I've adjusted this in my revision. I’m looking forward to your impressions on the revision! Cheers, …Alex |
Hi again, Alex—I googled "New Order" with "movement," to avoid the band, and then I got New Order’s album, Movement, haha. And I tried other search words and still didn’t find anything. So, for now, I'll guess that it’s a militant, perhaps cult-like faction (as their minds are "closed as a barred window"). I don’t know how important it is for the poem re the background on this. Or maybe it’s something I should be aware of anyway…
The "dunks of stone” line I think is much clearer now—I understood it the first time around, but this is more reader-friendly. And I love the change to “message” in the last stanza. And the other changes before the last stanza work well, imo. I keep going over and over your closing stanza. I love the gist of it, and where the poem ends up, but I’m wondering if sharpening it a bit would be worthwhile. My idea might be to reduce it to two lines and perhaps end it in the general vicinity of “to guide his sketches, color his absence.” In the poem, he is drawing his observations, and “His crayons are the shades of body fluids” suggests, to me, a certain level of brutality, so something like the above might imply the necessity to make something up, make his absence less severe, etc.** For whatever that's worth. As I mentioned before, I think this is great work, and hopefully something here will be of use. **Added: The above was initially intended to be just an example of something that gets there a bit faster. I got a little carried away... |
Hello again, James,
Thanks for returning to this and taking the time to look over the revision. I’m glad to know it reads more clearly now. On “New Order,” it’s funny (and telling!) what Google served up! I’d hoped it would be taken at face value—as referring to a sociopolitical system or movement—but I can appreciate that it might not come through precisely enough, given all the other connotations and references floating around. Your ruminations on the closing stanza are genuinely helpful, and I’ll definitely be mulling them over as I work toward a final shape. And no need at all to apologize for the expansiveness of your thoughts—I appreciated it all! Cheers, …Alex P.S. -- And a few new tweaks have been applied. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:47 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.