Thread: Sonnet #1
View Single Post
  #6  
Unread 04-15-2011, 07:18 AM
Petra Norr's Avatar
Petra Norr Petra Norr is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 1,592
Default

About the "manifold commands" which some have mentioned...
First of all, I already have a feeling I might be the only one to see the poem the way I do -- that the woman's men either fell in war or died of war-related injuries later. On a "personal" level. it's not impossible that Ms Thompson's male family members & lovers really did die in or from a war. But since I don't know Ms Thomson I take the poem to a general level and what I myself see is all the men being singled out as dead and the women alive. And on a general level, that can be read as the effects of war. The last lines -- the couplet -- can be seen as saying that, yes, it takes strength to go to war, it takes courage, but for the women who lose their men in war, it takes strength & courage to bury them, to live with the loss.
And back to "manifold commands", though spoken by the daughters, I think the phrase also conjures up military commands that the men would have heard in war.
Reply With Quote