Henry, I don't think anyone has a problem with a well-reasoned disagreement with another person's critique. It's the wholesale dismissal of someone's critique as being "too easy" or "too dumb to get it".
Not posting edits doesn't mean that a person is ignoring critique. Some people prefer to put their poems away for a long time and revise them later, after they've gotten some distance from the original. Others might have revisions already in mind and all that's needed to trigger it is a few good comments.
-eaf
|