This is fun, of course. Remember, though, what Oscar Wilde said with such truth -- you're in trouble when everyone nominates you, because it means you are derivative:
"Oh, he writes just like Richard Wilbur!" You are also in trouble when nobody approves you, for reasons which are self-evident. Or ought to be.
The likeliest for the canon are the mixed-review writers. The ones which get an equal chorus of "Hear! Hear!" and "You are crazy" at their nominations
J