Several months ago we had a similar comparison of the rawness of Billie Holiday's vocals, in comparison with the elegant finesse of Ella Fitzgerald.
Who was the "better" singer, technically speaking? Ella was, no question.
But I can't deny the visceral force of Billie's voice sometimes, precisely because it's stripped so bare of artifice, apparent skill, etc. I get the impression that I'm in the presence of naked, honest emotion.
Although I'm not a big fan of his work, the same applies to Dylan, sometimes, for me.
Others' mileage may vary.
|