Thread: X
View Single Post
  #30  
Unread 10-25-2016, 09:06 AM
David Danoff David Danoff is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Darnestown, MD
Posts: 803
Default

I almost suggested making this shorter: 4 or 6 lines of set up, followed by the couplet.

But I think the larger problem is the mishmash quality of the list. If all the details contributed, subtly, to an atmosphere of curdled romance, disappointment, longing, self-blame, whatever--it would work at 6 lines, or it work as a sonnet.

As it is, we've got some stuff that I think does contribute to setting up the couplet (promised cache of treasure, unknown quantity, chromosome, infinity), but a bunch of other stuff mixed in that's off in terms of content and tone (skull and crossbones, ballplayers, clothing size). And some stuff that could go either way.

I could see having a more positive response to the ending, if I felt like the rest of the poem had (however subtly) set us up for the personal revelation.
Reply With Quote