Stuart,
I have had a winning Bake-off poem published.
Conventional glory does no harm.
It's acceptable for a judge to add to the discussion if that's what the judge wants.
It's not OK for a selector to take the place of the judge. I'm sure Cathy didn't realise what it implied when she suggested it.
If there were a separate contest judged by Cathy it would be entirely a different matter. Those would be the terms of admittance.
Janet
Last edited by Janet Kenny; 03-13-2009 at 07:07 PM.
|