Hi. Actual American Indian here. What a lively and engaging thread, how could I have missed this? Thanks to Julie for her email today alerting me to this.
The casual dismissals of Senator Warren's infraction here are at least as offensive as the racial rhetoric. Let's maybe look at what some real live Indian activists had to say about it. First, Navajo journalist and activist, Jacqueline Keeler:
https://tiyospayenow.blogspot.com/20...ttachment.html
"I’d say Sen. Warren’s continued assertion without a shred of evidence of a single connection to anyone from the Cherokee or Delaware nations is unacceptable to the citizens of those nations. You should see the responses I get from Native people when I share on social media even the mildest mention of her. Her insistence on it, even after genealogists found zero ties in her family tree, and in light of citizens of Cherokee and Delaware nations asking her to stop doing so is harmful in that it degrades their nations' sovereign rights to determine who their citizens are and who they are not. As head of state of the sole super power in the world, or even as a US Senator, she must deal with them on a political level. And I should note, in fact, the only ties genealogists found that could be verified between members of her family tree and any Indian nation were as
Indian killers."
Now a bona fide citizen enrolled in the Cherokee Nation, activist Rebecca Nagle, writing at HuffPost:
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/opini...b08aaf7a96cab2
"Chuck Hoskin, the secretary of state of the Cherokee Nation ― the tribe Warren claims to descend from ― issued a statement that the move was 'inappropriate and wrong,' and the senator was 'undermining tribal interests with her continued claims of tribal heritage.' Meanwhile, several Native critics published op-eds calling Warren’s decision 'cringeworthy,' 'a vicious rejection of Native sovereignty,' 'pure opportunism' and 'highly destructive to Native people.'”
As an aside, Hoskin is now Principal Chief of the Cherokee Nation. He was secretary of state under former Principal Chief Bill John Baker, who used to follow me on Twitter and retweet my posts, although he is no longer active on the site. It's a pity because Chief Bill was an inspiring, ingenious orator and writer who seemed to like me. Find and read him if you can.
With respect to all,
Jennifer