Villanelle on a Line from the New York Times Book Review
(or An Excoriation upon Strunk and White's The Elements of Style)
A quote, "I hate the guts of English grammar,"
is lifted from the pen of E. B. White.
Well, so do we all. But most of us are dumber
than White with words. He and old Strunk, his mentor,
knew in their bones and gizzards how to write
well, but both were incompetents at grammar.
Now freshmen in their composition slumber
are told
No passives! But wrong examples blight
the lesson, leaving them at sea. What's dumber,
each exhortation whacks us like a hammer:
Be clear. Omit the needless words. All right,
but how? You
need the guts of English grammar
to brace the words, to get them not to stammer.
Mostly we give it up without a fight,
texting and e-mail smiting us dumb and dumber.
That's why I gave my copy to my daughter.
She might not laugh (but then again, she might).
So White hated the guts of English grammar?
So do we all. But most of us are dumber.
(You might need to refer to this thread to make sense of the poem:
http://www.ablemuse.com/erato/showth...t=Strunk+White