[Matt Q]

Hi Jayne,

I do appreciate that mods can't see everything and that they have a limited amount of time available. I wasn't suggesting everything was left to the mods, but more that it might be better if members referred grievances and accusations of misconduct against other members to the mods rather than trying to sort them out themselves.

I don't mean things like politely pointing out minor infringements or points of information "did you notice that you've posted that poem 6 days after the last one" or "by the way did you know you can't post your first poem until you've posted 15 crits and you've only posted 10", "please can you show the original poem as well as the revision" and so on. I'm more talking about members telling each other off, making accusations of misconduct, of wrongdoing: members standing in judgement over one another. That just doesn't seem like a great idea to me. Lots of potential for ill-will, arguments etc., with no one actually having the power to enforce anything. Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe there are positives to it too.

In the guidelines it says this:

Problems – Member Conduct

You should raise reminders or complaints, especially ones involving Moderators, in private by PM, not in public on the Forums.

I had always taken this to mean that public confrontation/accusations by members about other member's conduct was to be avoided. Quite possibly I've misunderstood this, or it no longer implies.

All the best,

-Matt

[Jayne Osborn]

You're not wrong, Matt, and members often do tip us the wink when there's a bit of trouble brewing or something needs dealing with.

But it's impossible to stop those who are outraged by something and can't hold back from saying so to the ''offender''!

Inevitably, we also get the deliberate trouble-makers (trolls) once in a while; they aren't always readily identifiable, so it's necessary to be a bit circumspect sometimes...

All in all, though, regarding the ''State of the Sphere" I find it a great place to be, where I've made lots of really good friends.
Long may it continue.

Jayne

[Shaun J. Russell]

I should also mention that thread reports are pretty uncommon. We get maybe one per month. While I don't want to outright suggest that members use the "report" function more often, it is a good way to catch a mod's attention in the span of (usually) a few hours.

[Matt Q]

Jayne,

Yes, I like being here too, the majority of the time, and I'm very glad the Sphere exists and persists. Perhaps we should occasionally have a thread devoted to what we like about this place?

- Matt

[Roger Slater]

It occurs to me that another advantage of a password-protected forum would be that there wouldn't be a need to prune it -- though possibly people would want their work pruned at some point anyway.

[W.F. Lantry]

Originally Posted by Matt Q

I had always taken this to mean that public confrontation/accusations by members about other member's conduct was to be avoided. Quite possibly I've misunderstood this, or it no longer implies.

Matt,

No, you haven't misunderstood. That's how it's supposed to be. But it's a universal truism that those most zealous in wanting rules enforced tend not to follow the rules themselves. Just today, I heard about a case of a legislator a couple years ago. He'd zealously led the fight against medical marijuana. Then he got busted with an ounce of his own. By his own state's police. While driving...

Best,

Bill

[Norman Ball]

We can overdo the negative. Here's some high praise for Eratosphere in the Swarthmore Phoenix from Ian Hoffman:

"Is the fact that [Hoffman] emailed the poem via Internet, instead of writing it out with his hands, more important a gesture to analyze, in historical terms, than the fact that Hoffman credits Internet forums such as Eratosphere and the broad community of published and amateur poets he found there as being inherently crucial to the development of his craft?"

http://swarthmorephoenix.com/2014/09...to-the-poetry/

On a separate note, we recently kicked around the journalism vs. poetry theme across the fence on Jake Sheff's 'Ode on Christmas' Keats' here.